Thursday, January 14, 2010
The Germ of an idea: microhealth
The problem: debilitating mental illness and mental impairment is a huge burden in rural India. Let's face it, it's no picnic in the UK, but in India it is catastrophic. According to the WHO only 1% of India's health budget is spent on mental health. There are a puny 3500 psychiatrists in India. By that I am not passing judgement on their stature or relative musculature. Considering there is a lifetime prevalence of 22% of mental illness in a country of 1 billion, 3500 psychiatrists does not go very far. Of course most of those doctors will be in the cities and as already mentioned earlier in the blog, 70% of the country’s population is rural. Mental health in the villages is in a dismal situation: there is quite simply no help.
So starting any mental health program is a gargantuan task. The need is enormous and the resources microscopic. When Dr Rita, Dr Annie and I first spoke about this last year, fresh from the introduction to asset mapping as opposed to needs assessment, we explored the new concept of figuring out how, given that they have absolutely nothing, these people are managing; because somehow, however crappily, they are; like the elderly at Keelalathur before we came along to offer food, who were also somehow managing. They had a life. It probably was not great, but we did not account for any of it and as a result we simply increased dependence.
Dependence in mental health is ruinous for two reasons, firstly it impedes recovery and welfare, secondly, it unleashes the untameable beast of unmeetable need. No health care service can solve the problem of mental illness; it's not like removing footprints from a polished floor. Mental illness is messy, complicated, intrusive, pervasive and, most of all, endemic. In fact, most of all, it is embedded within the lives of individuals and their community. Solutions therefore must necessarily mostly be born from within those communities. Any health care professional who fails to acknowledge that from the start is starting a long journey across a hot desert in a thermal snowsuit with lead weights in his boots. Without water. Or a phone. In other words, it is madness. The astounding thing is that the madness of mental illness is indeed in those very professionals for the idea of actually asking people how they cope is not only incredibly new, but it is not done well: "Ask a mad person how to manage their mental illness? Are you mad? That would be like asking a heart translant patient if they had any hot, new suturing tips." It would appear then, that the idea of starting a project with this concept is new. I’ve researched it and I cannot find anything along these lines. If anyone knows of anything similar I would love to hear of it.
So, the plan: at RUHSA there is an occupational therapy clinic for children with mental impairment. There are some extremely keen mothers who come every week and have already noticed a difference. These mothers have to look after their children 24/7 so there is no time to do any income generating activities. The double whammy of illness and poverty. So the plan is to tap into this keenness and have a training session for these women. Firstly, learn how they manage – effective techniques can be disseminated to others. Secondly, equip them with generic skills for caring such as hygiene, nutrition etc. Add in specific skills for children with learning difficulties and adults with severe and enduring mental health needs. Then, and here is the genius bit, train them to look after more than person. Now send them back to the village with back up from the community staff already in place, such as RUHSA’s Rural Community Officers, family care volunteers, health aids who have been working for the medical care team for the last 30 years, who will now be additionally trained to recognise and destigmatise mental illness in order to identify other families in the village in need. Let the women in their own community persuade other families of the benefit of OT work and then encourage them come for training and then to form co-operatives so that the care burden can be shared. This will allow some women to be relieved of their 24/7 caregiving role to enable them to generate an income which can be shared. As more people benefit, the training programs can become more specialist and directive according to need. It seems to be a win win situation. Serious problems are more likely to be delflected with better care or recognised with increased experience and then can be directed as appropriate to the medical team.
This idea is so simple, I like to call it microhealth because, like microfinance, it draws on the big ideas, but brings them to a simple, manageable practical solution for the individual and leaves the medics to deal with cases which cannot be managed except by medication. The outlay of the mental health system then becomes training plus appropriate, hardcore management rather than getting bogged down by taking on problems indiscriminately; the momentum and power is generated by the community, for itself.
I think you’ll agree, it’s genius in its simplicity, but as I mentioned before, this is just the beginning and the road to make this idea a reality will be long and hard. It will need passion and dedication and effective leadership to make it work: Dr Rita & Dr Annie embody these values.
Wednesday, January 13, 2010
Waffle vs Ryvita
The most exciting piece of news, which I forgot to mention in the first posting is that after three years of coming and having to sleep on a twice baked ryvita mattress (the dimply side) I have been awarded the honour of being given a proper, no coir, foamy, spongy, bouncy, thick, cosy, deep, enveloping, DELICIOUS new mattress. It is impossible to describe the joy I felt when I sat down on the bed, expecting to go "crunch" and instead going "squish". My brain could barely compute the significance of the signals coming from my bum. No longer do I have to put the two mattresses together to give a semblance of substance beyond tungsten carbide to my sleep. Despite the addition of a slightly thicker coir mattress last time - which sandwiched between the other two wafers, created a marginally less horrific night's sleep, I still developed pressure sores albeit to a lesser depth than without the coir mattress, but now! NOW! Now, I sink into blissful slumber as soon as my head hits the brick. (A comfy pillow is a step too far). Anyway, thank you to the Gods of Nighttime Torture, that they have taken pity on me and facilitated this new look RUHSA room.
As if a new mattress were not enough, however, when I walked into the bathroom, I saw to my absolute delight a newly fitted electric hot water cylinder. Oh. My. GOD! I am going to be able to have an appropriately temperature-regulated shower. No more freezing ones in the morning (when it's cold) or tepid ones in the afternoon (when it's boiling). With shining eyes and clapping hands I turned excitedly towards one of the Henchmen. My smile dropped. An imperceptible head wobble did not bode well. Wafting his hand towards the gleaming new apparatus I heard the devastating words, "not working", crushing my new found hope. It's true, not only is it not plugged in (and the socket too far from the cylinder) but it is not attached to a water source. As such it is merely decorative and very beautiful it looks too. Still, one step at a time. How things have changed even since I first came here three years ago. I have high hopes that next visit I will have a sit-down loo, a comfy mattress AND hot water. Woohoo.
Monday, January 11, 2010
A New Year, a New Visit, a New Director and a New Start
Our meeting in January 1989 over 20 years ago was inspirational for me then; there was a propitious sense then, but I was not to know how influential in many ways that first meeting would be. I remember so clearly our trip to the tribal village by jeep aged 18. As we crossed a dried river bed, bouncing against the hard springs, we passed a woman being carried in a makeshift sling by two men. She was still and cachectic. With her huge bulging stomach, a visible ovarian tumour beneath the paperleaf skin, she looked like a child's badly made doll. Dr John stopped to talk to the men. The woman was incapable of doing anything more exhausting than breathing. She was being brought home to die. The faintly glowing embers of interest in medicine in me were fanned. Many years, and several arguments later, despite our often fractious interactions, I am very grateful to him and all he has done for me.
Dr John's leaving, however, means that a good friend and excellent person is now director of RUHSA and I am delighted not only at her achievements, but also at her keenness to continue my association here, working on nothing less than my main interest - mental health. I wish Dr Rita Isaac best wishes for her and RUHSA's furture success. I have every confidence in her.
So far 2010 has had a great start and I can't wait to get stuck in. Early plans suggest that she is keen for me to start looking at community resources for mental health. Mental illness has a huge impact on poor families in rural India - family members are sacrificed to look after the ill person and therefore not only is there a loss of income to medical care but also because of loss of working capacity. This results in mental ill children growing up neglected, tied to cots, restrained, being mistreated and reaching very much less than their full capacity in the strive for families to manage. It is extremely tough. However, mental institutions can neither cope nor provide the answer necessarily. The starting point for sustainable mental care is to look at what communities already do and try to help them to do it better in conjunction with delivering appropriate medical care. A cluster of families with mentally ill relatives have been identified and we are going to explore the idea of developing co-operatives between them. Anything like this whichde velops within the community must evolve through community potential and not be imposed, so I expect the road to the right solution will be long and occasionally disheartening, but I have no doubts that it is the correct path to be taking.
Sunday, July 19, 2009
Belated update
Ostensibly, I went out as part of my cunning plan to "encourage" RUHSA to finish the building works on the CHEW (Community health education and welfare) buildings in which we were planning to start two other elderly welfare centres. Ie, the cunning plan was to announce a Grand Opening (with photo opportunities) in order to create a deadline to be met, rather than an open-ended timeframe. Oringially the Grand Opening was planned for August, then it was moved forwards to July and finally, much to the distress of those whose responisbility it was to actually deliver the goods before the deadline (ie not the person who was swayed by the thought of the photo opportunities) it was brought forwards to June. So the date was set that two trustees, Dr William Cutting and myself, would come out to open the CHEW buildings at Kovasambet and Sholamur respectively on Monday 22nd June. William would then go on to other meeting whilst I went on to other fun.
Prior to going to RUHSA, I met Celine, who has the women's refuge centre/Home of Compassion in Bangalore. We are trying to set up a website for her so people can donate money to her work. Her aim is to establish a core capital fund, from which there would be interest and income generated to enable her pay for any children's schooling, so no-one remains disadvantaged by circumstances. So far she is already paying (with some sponsorship) for about 7 children's schooling. And she is fussy, the cheapest school will not do, she wants the best. This still only costs about £300 a year, but that is a substantial amount to find if there is no income. She also thinks it is important for women to have some possessions of their own to take into a future marriage with them, even if this happens many years after they leave her care. As these women usually arrive with nothing, the only person who can provide these - usually it comes from the brides family - is Celine, who becomes their new family, often. As soon as the website is up and running I will post it. It is looking good so far.
RUHSA had planned a full and interesting day for William and myself.
In the morning, there were the ceremonial openings, Willam opened the building at Kovasambet and I opened the Sholamur building. I even have a plaque which was revealed by pulling on a little curtain! After I opened the curtain I had to cut the ribbon into the building.Unfortunately, someone had forgotten to arrange for a pair of scissors, so for a while, I thought I would have to improvise and gnaw through the ribbon with my teeth. Eventually, with much puffing and panting, a local teenager ran back from the village carrying a huge, blunt pair of comedy scissors. It took a while to get through the ribbon. I think my teeth would have been better and it wouldn't have given me RSI on my wrist.
We also visited the original health centre where the elderly are enjoying the fruits of the goat scheme. Several goats have had two kids, enabling the owners to give one back to RUHSA as part of the pass it on scheme but also sell one to make money. I was a bit concerned that we might simply have generated a means of causing several fractured neck of femurs, as the goats yanked their frail owners towards something tasty looking (see left), but apparently they all know when to let go of the rope. The picture on the right shows a couple of generations of goat owners.
Saturday, February 21, 2009
Thursday, February 05, 2009
From balmy PK Puram to Snowy London*
Am back in the UK now, after a blissful week travelling around the western ghats and Indian Ocean coastline relaxing and trying to get a tan. I have managed to get a good hand tan, but my face just looks dirty. I am slightly concerned that it will in fact all wash off in the bath, which makes me reluctant to have one. Think it's getting to the point I need both metaphorically and literally to take the plunge. All in all this trip was much more of a success than I ever expected. I was quite pessimistic about what I would find, how I would be greeted and what I would do, but in fact it has surpassed expectation. Of course, there was the minor hiccup of no-one knowing I was coming, but I was half expecting that, given previous form. However, unlike last year, they did seem more pleased to see me! Once the initial hurdle of getting my room ready, everything was fine. In fact there were some advantages to coming unexpectedly because no-one polished things up to present to me, I saw it all in it's unprepared state and the elderly centres really have a life of their own now and look like being an easily replicatable model. The group from Bishopston in Bristol, who are setting up a play and teaching resource centre want to use one of the spare rooms for a similar elderly welfare . The exciting potential consequence for this is that there will be a juxtaposition of the elderly and very young. One of the ideas about the sustainability of the first centre was to use the physical presence of the elderly as a kind of baby sitting/creche service. This did not seem very culturally acceptable at the time, but the propinquity in the Bishopston centre may result in a natural evolution of this, making it much more acceptable and therefore, potentially be used in other areas. So another really exciting avenue is opened and we will see how it develops. In addition to this, building works have actually started in the new centres, there will be a "Grand Opening" in August (ploy to accelerate the building works), which will give me an exucse to come out again (hurrah), although for a shorter time (boo). Here are some pictures to show works in progress.


Of course the other interesting development is the mental health project proposal. During my last couple of days there I attended a couple of lectures on mental health in the community which were fascinating. Suicide is a huge problem in India, although studies suggest that unlike in the UK, the proportion which are due to mental illness is only about 1/3, meaning 2/3 probably commit suicide for socioeconomical reasons. In addition, unlike the developing world, more women than men commit suicide and of those there are 2 peaks, the first, horrifyingly, is in the 15-25 age range and the second in the >65y olds. This is such a waste of life. Most people who commit suicide do so through quite definitive and likely to be successful means - poisoning, eg organophosphate poisoning, drowning, hanging. The implications of all this are that there need to be significant population based approaches to prevention, for example more sociostructural support, outlawing of poisonous substances etc, rather than simply measures targeting mental health, because these measures would only capture a small proportion of people who commit suicide.Interestingly, the lecturer mentioned, as an important strategy, the need to map community assets. Very excited I went up to him afterwards and asked what research had been done in this area. None, he said. Ah, well, that is both disappointing and thrilling. I look forward to cutting a wave (or falling flat on my face!)
*attr. Lot Onslow in sms circa 2007
Wednesday, January 21, 2009
Signs of the Times
I saw this when going to buy the tickets to the jungle. I thought it most appropriate.

This is the sign for school children crossing the road. The fear of imminent death is plainly conveyed even in this monochrome silhouette as the child pegs it across the road to dodge the lethal traffic.
Tuesday, January 20, 2009
Concentration at Kovasambet
It was noticeable that they were a cheekier bunch, asking me directly what I was doing there, which I thought was great. They seemed less “grateful”, which seemed to translate into feeling less disempowered. We had a great discussion where they told me about themselves and then asked me about myself. One lady, who was particularly funny and vocal, made the universal sign – clenched fists and flexed pumping biceps conveying astonishment at enormity (fat not muscular) and asked me why I had come all the way from England to look at her. Good question. Telling her about the plan to start welfare centres elsewhere, I answered that they were helping me understand how these places could work well. She replied – you ask us if we are happy, but what about you, are you happy? Jebaraj, who was translating this, was astonished at her frankness, but it was perfect because it helped normalise our relative statuses and made us interesting to one another, rather than relating to one another as provider and recipient. Several other women, well aware of this lady’s frankness, were shaking their heads and smiling in mock despair, but the whole exchange provided much amusement and was a great ice-breaker. By the end of the morning we were all sitting in a circle with me trying to teach them “Concentration” which is a rhythmic game of clapping and pointing to others whilst trying to keep up the rhythm.
Up a tree hiding from elephants Part II
Forest Hills is a resort is owned by a family who came here from Himachel Pradesh to farm, but found the local vermin a little difficult to manage. Crop growing here needs to be resistant not just to various insects, but also deer, boar, bison and of course elephants. Rahul, the youngest son told me that the deer jump the cattle grids and the elephants just barge through whatever fencing is put up. In other words, there is no stopping an elephant who wants to snack on some papaya or indeed whatever takes their fancy. Even an elephant with an itch is a menace, because most structures, the spindly legs of tree houses included, will not stand up to being used as a scratching post by a 10 tonne elephant. The family therefore decided to abandon farming and start a jungle safari lodge.
Arun had organised us to stay in one of their tree-houses, which was a house on stilts wrapped around a tree. I refer you to Maddy’s blog (http://www.madelainescragg.blogspot.com/) for some excellent pictures of Maddy climbing the internal tree. Sadly, there is no photo of the expression on Maddy’s face when she woke up after a mammoth sleep catch up (11½ hours) and first encountered the unexpected tree in her bedroom.
We had a fabulous time at the resort. On the first night we went for a safari, which basically consisted of bumping around the roads in Garuda, with Ravi stopping and exchanging tracking tips with other guides to get to see the best animals. The place was teeming with excited tourists all keen to see wild elephants, which I guess is the equivalent to trucks of Biharis driving excitedly around the Lake District trying to get to spot a rabbit or too. We did see some, and they were totally adorable - big, lumbering, brown, dusty beasts with faraway looks in their tiny eyes, guarding a titchy-trunked baby. Compared to the domesticated elephants they seemed plumper and less concerned with life. I guess being unstoppable and persistently photographed will give you that air.
I interrupt this entry with an exciting news flash. Dr Rita has given me a new mattress!!!!!!!! On it’s own, being coir (coconut matting) it is quite hard, but I can tell you, sandwiched between the two ryvita gave me the best night sleep, perched as I was, precariously, on 3 mattresses high above my bed like a pea on a drum, that I have ever had at RUHSA. Hallelujah. I even snuck in an extra kip at lunch time.
On the second day of the safari, we went to a Nilgiri Tea Estate in search of Tea Nirvana – ie the perfect cuppa. Since I visited tea estates in Assam all those years ago I have loved them. They are like beautiful sculpted slopes, plucked to an even undulating height, interspersed with peppercorn wrapped shade trees. The factories still contain machines brought over by Europeans over 100 years ago – in this case Irish – which roll, sort and dry the tea. It’s astonishing, to think that the process of making a cuppa has not changed at all in over a century. Certainly, it looked exactly the same as it did in Assam in 1995. Radically, the manager said that within 6m it’s all going to be computerised. I can’t imagine they will last into the next century.
That night, as Maddy and I lay in our little eyrie, she worm-like in a sleeping bag, me blissfully happily wrapped in several blankets, we heard the unmistakable sound of a nearby bull elephant, trumpeting loudly. He sounded quite cross. We fervently hoped he didn’t have an uncontrollable itch.
Monday, January 19, 2009
Up a tree hiding from elephants Part I
Maddy is the daughter of a friend of mine who has been teaching spoken English in classes run by Celine. Last year, Celine asked me if I knew anyone who wanted to spend 6m in India teaching as a volunteer. Maddy was the first and only person suggested, but she and a friend turned up trumps and have been here since September, although her friend, Sarah, has since gone home. Celine specified that she wanted someone English to help perfect their accent which is the hardest thing for them to master out here apparently. Entertainingly, although Maddy has quite a posh voice, Sarah is full frontal Barrovian, so somewhere in deepest Bangalore, there is a little group of Indians walking around speaking English with a thick northern accent, saying things like, “Where’s the rickshaw at?” no doubt thinking they speak like the queen because they were taught by a genuine Englishwoman.
Sadly, Celine was not free this weekend as she had booked herself in for her annual and much deserved retreat. Consequently, it was just Maddy and myself who set off for a Nadventure. After some indecision, we plumped for a safari trip, staying in a tree house. Arun arranged it all so, not really knowing what we were in for, we set off on a night bus to somewhere near Ooty, to which I had never been before. Arun had given us comprehensive, if a little complicated instructions, like get off half way up the mountain at some unpronounceable place at 4 in the morning and there will be a jeep waiting for you to take you to the resort. Feeling the weight of responsibility for a young girl 20 years my junior (aaaaaaggghhh – how weird is that? I guess if I had my own children, not weird at all, but as I don’t and barely feel older than 18 myself sometimes, I found it most peculiar), I made every precaution of making sure the conductor knew what we wanted to do. I spoke to him, I phoned the manager of the resort and he spoke to him – in three languages – and smiled encouragingly every time he wafted past me to check tickets. He was a handsome man with the usual look of Tom Selleck but the additional feature of sparkly violent pink nail varnish on his left hand (maybe to give his bum something exciting to look at). Finally, confident I had done everything to ensure all went to plan and there was no crisis with which to traumatise Maddy and introduce her too early to the Arabella way of travel, I dozed on the bumpy, slidy seats.
Pink-taloned Tom told me that the bus would arrive Somewhere Unpronounceable at 5 in the morning. Waking as someone got off at 4.15, I took advantage of the brief moment of bus calm and went to the front to remind him to tell us when to get off. He was sleeping, his cheek resting on his magenta nailed hand. He flapped me away irritatedly with his undecorated hand. The bus moved on. Suddenly he woke up and went to talk to the driver. The bus stopped. All the lights went on. He gestured towards me. I went up to the front to talk to him. The conversation did not flow easily, but the gist of it was that we had passed our unpronounceable destination a while back. Leaning casually against the drivers counter, he airly said that it was not a problem we could catch a bus back in the other direction. Just a small, small trip. At 4 in the morning. With no idea how to pronounce the bloody place name and an expectant 18 year old, assuming I was in charge.
Acquiring some of his airiness, I breezily updated Maddy, acting as if this was all part of the plan. Luckily, I had the phone number of the resort manager so Ravi and Garuda, his trusty jeep (about which more in the next chapter), wove their way further up into the jungle and found us huddled together in the cold mountain air, drinking chai with a couple of bemused local men who couldn’t believe their early morning luck at having two gorgeous beauties chance upon their normally dull, pre-dawn routine. Ok so, one beauty and a fearsome-looking, if ineffective, chaperone.




